Polarizing Pictures: Films that Left the Audience Split

Films that are considered polarizing get their fair share of love and hate. Obviously, there are films considered to be classics such as Titanic or Citizen Kane. There are the objectively “bad” films that have gained a cult following over the years like The Room. But then there are the films that don’t exactly fit either category but are still known for having split viewers straight down the middle. From big blockbusters to popular small budget pictures, there are many films that seem to put people in opposing camps. Here are some that fall into that category.

Avatar (2009)

James Cameron’s Avatar was the highest grossing film worldwide for nearly a decade until it was dethroned by Marvel’s Avengers: Endgame in 2019. Although it spent about 10 years holding that elusive title (and actually recently reclaimed it after a re-release in China this past year), it’s a film that many seem to disagree on. Those who are fans point out its intricate worldbuilding along with the visual and technical feats. The film is credited with popularizing 3D effects, which in 2009 understandably made for an immersive and unforgettable viewing experience. On the other hand, those who dislike the film have called out the script for lacking in originality and depth, making it difficult not to see it as highly overrated after considering its massive success. Four sequels are scheduled to be released, so a lot of time to make up your mind!

My opinion on the film: Somehow I’ve seen this three times and I don’t think I will ever get the hype.

mother! (2017)

Darren Aronofsky’s psychological horror mother! is a film that proved to be polarizing upon its premiere, receiving a standing ovation amidst many boos at the Venice Film Festival. Starring Jennifer Lawrence as “Mother” and Javier Bardem as her poet husband “Him”, mother! seemingly follows the couple living a quiet life in their large Victorian-style house. When guests start showing up uninvited, “Mother” becomes increasingly disturbed. Filled with biblical allegories and symbolism, mother! is praised by fans as a shocking and ambitious piece of filmmaking. Those who disagree regarded the film as overly pretentious and many also criticized its grotesque depiction of violence.

My opinion on the film: Well, it sure is something. Teetering on brilliance all the while being completely nauseating.

Star Wars: The Last Jedi (2017)

Star Wars is a beloved franchise and there is no doubt that there has been some divisiveness over the years, but I think The Last Jedi is probably the most polarizing film to date. Many admired director Rian Johnson’s attempt to take the franchise in a different direction, finding the focus on different character arcs and the bold choices to be refreshing. However, for a large number of fans the film failed to live up to expectations. Many took issue with characterization and plot points, feeling as though the film failed to consider years of history, and instead considered Johnson’s move to be a massive miscalculation in moving forward with the legendary Skywalker saga.

My opinion on the film: I got to see this in theaters a couple of days after its release and haven’t seen it since. I wasn’t its biggest fan then but that said, I definitely think it’s time for a rewatch. I did love the visuals though.

Spring Breakers (2012)

The A24 film Spring Breakers has received a lot of attention ever since its release. The film follows four college girls on their spring break where they eventually meet a local drug dealer and fall into his world of crime. The film was praised for its stylish aesthetic and commentary on youth culture, with many fans finding it fresh and creative. Others found the film to be distasteful, feeling that the characters were poorly written and any attempt at satire missed the mark, making it overall trashy - and not in a good way.

My opinion on the film: I actually haven’t seen it yet… ask me another time!

Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas (1998)

Based on the Hunter S. Thompson novel of the same name, Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas is truly a psychedelic experience and that might be the reason as to why it makes this list. Starring Johnny Depp and Benicio del Toro, Fear and Loathing follows two men on their drug fueled adventures in Las Vegas. Fans fully embrace the film’s wackiness, appreciating its satire and visual style. Those who find themselves on the opposite side find it completely aimless and way too outlandish. Director Terry Gilliam actually stated that he wanted the film to be polarizing. Looks like he got his wish.

My opinion on the film: I stopped about 20 minutes in because I just knew it was not going to be my thing. Maybe I should give it a second chance?

Showgirls (1995)

Since its release, Showgirls has been trashed on, reevaluated, and picked apart by many. The film has a jarring rating distribution on Letterboxd with an almost equal number of one star and five star ratings. Showgirls follows Nomi (played by Elizabeth Berkley) who makes her way to Vegas in hopes of making it as a headline showgirl. Known for its graphic nature, the film was (and still is) heavily criticized for its depiction of nudity and violence. Many also find the acting and screenplay laughable. On the other hand, those who praise the film assert that it achieves its goal of being a serious satire. Over the years, many have come to view Showgirls as a misunderstood masterpiece.

My opinion on the film: I’m definitely Team Misunderstood Masterpiece! There are some aspects that I might consider questionable, but there is a very camp quality to it.

Vanilla Sky (2001)

Cameron Crowe’s sci-fi thriller Vanilla Sky (a remake of the 1997 Spanish film Open Your Eyes) stars Tom Cruise as rich playboy David Aames, who, after getting into a horrific car accident, tries to get his life back on track as the line between what’s real and what isn’t starts to blur. Fans of the film compliment its thought-provoking themes and use of tension. Those who are critical of the film point out the protagonist as unlikeable and feel as though the plot gets too complicated as it goes on, making for a confusing mess of a film.

My opinion on the film: I didn’t hate it but I can’t say I loved it. For a polarizing film, I feel very in the middle about this one.